
Trey Yesavage was the Blue Jays’ first-round draft pick in 2024. He made it to the Jays in September 2025, made three starts, then made five starts and a relief appearance in our playoff run with a 3.58 ERA. In 27.2 innings, he allowed 18 hits, 11 walks, and had 39 strikeouts. The Jays were hoping that teams would have problems with his ‘over the top’ delivery. His pitches come off his hand at 7.1 feet off the ground (decimal points in imperial measurements look so weird to me), and it seemed they did.
We wondered how he would do in a full season. Unfortunately, we didn’t find out as he missed a fair bit of time with an injury.
When he did pitch, it went well:
| Age | WAR | W | L | ERA | G | GS | GF | CG | IP | H | R | ER | HR | BB | IBB | SO | HBP | BK | WP | BF | ERA+ | FIP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 | 2.0 | 5 | 6 | 3.69 | 20 | 20 | 0 | 0 | 97.2 | 64 | 41 | 40 | 12 | 47 | 0 | 97 | 2 | 0 | 4 | 401 | 120 | 4.22 |
Baseball Reference has him at 2.0 WAR, and Fangraphs has him at 1.3, valuing him at $10.0 million to the Blue Jays.
Trey had a 4.22 FIP and 4.57 xFIP which explains why his fWAR is lower than his bWAR
He had a .214 BABIP (team average .283). 74.8% of the base runners he allowed were stranded (team average 72.4).
Yesavage’s line drive rate was 16.4% (team average 19.4). His ground ball rate was 32.2% (team 42.3). And the fly ball rate was 50.4% (team 38.2). 8.1% of his fly balls left the park 9.5% of the time (team 11.0).
His strikeout rate was 24.2% (team 23.1), while his walk rate was up 11.7% (team 9.7).
Trey’s soft contact rate was 16.1% (team 17.2). Hard contact was 31.8% (team 32.3).
He was slightly better vs. RHB (..174/.263/.356) than LHB (.195/.300/.349).
Yesavage was better on the road (batters hit.172/.281/.316 with a 3.20 ERA) than at home (.200/.287/.388 with a 4.21 ERA).
He was about the same in the first half (3.72, .182/.288/.333) as the second half (3.57, .200/.270/.413), but he only pitched 22.2 innings in the second half.
Yesavage by month:
- April: 1 start, 1-0, 0.00. Batters hit .200/.200/.250 with 0 home runs, 0 walks and 3 strikeouts.
- May: 6 starts, 1-2, 2.56. Batters hit .202/.313/.284 with 0 home runs, 17 walks and 36 strikeouts.
- June: 5 starts, 2-1, 4.75. Batters hit .165/.258/.404 with 6 home runs, 13 walks and 22 strikeouts..
- July: 5 starts, 1-2, 4.81. Batters hit .198/.308/.372 with 2 home runs, 15 walks and 0 strikeouts.
- August: 1 start (just 2 innings), 0-0, 0.00. Batters hit .000/.143/.000 with 0 home runs, 1 walk and 30 strikeouts.
- September: 2 starts (4 innings), 0-1, 4.50. Batters hit .214/.267/.643 with 2 home run, 1 walks and 6 strikeouts.
The Jays were 7-13 in his starts. They averaged 3.63 runs per game in his starts. They scored 3 or fewer runs in 13 of his starts.
Days of rest:
- 4 days, 8 starts: 3-3, 2.85 ERA, batters hit .188/.276/.333.
- 5 days, 6 starts: 0-2, 4.23 ERA, batters hit .172/.289/.343.
- 6 or more days: 4 starts, 2-1, 4.42 ERA, batters hit .212/.289/.409.
By catcher:
- Tyler Heineman: 3 games, 14.1 innings: 1.26 ERA, batters hit .220/.350/.260.
- Alejandro Kirk: 9 games, 35 innings: 4.63 ERA, batters hit .171/.309/.358.
- Brandon Valenzuela: 8 games, 48.1 innings: 3.72 ERA, batters hit .187/.242/.374.
Times through the order:
- 1st: Batters hit .158/.257/.283’
- 2nd: Batters hit .185/.290/.290.
- 3rd: Batters hit .250/.333/.618
Trey was good with RISP, holding batters to a .149/.269/.216 line.
In high-leverage spots, batters hit .241/.343/.407. Low leverage .167/.254/.333.
His best start, according to GameScore, was a 76 on May 20th, at Yankee Stadium. He went 6 innings, allowing 2 hit, 0 walks, and 8 strikeouts.
The worst start was a 31 GameScore. July 7th, going 1.2 innings, allowing 1 hits, 4 earned run, 7 walks and 1 strikeouts in San Diego. 5 outs and 7 walks.
Trey averaged 4.9 innings per start.
Random Baseball Savant Numbers:
- xBA: 92nd percentile.
- Whiff %: 84th percentile.
- Barrel %: 65th percentile.
- Ground ball %: 11th percentile.
- Base on Balls %: 13th percentile.
It wasn’t the season we hoped for from Trey, mostly because of injuries. He had a shoulder issue at the start of the season and then missed time after ‘meniscus surgery’ in early August, throwing just four innings after that, near the end of the season. But it does look like we’ll enjoy watching him when he can put together an injury-free season.
I said, before the season, that his ‘over the top’ delivery does worry me. Sometimes, when you have a delivery so different from anyone else’s, we find out why no one else throws that way. But one season isn’t enough of a sample size to prove anything.
The team was careful with him during spring training and, well, it didn’t pay off. Not that being careful was what caused his injury troubles. It more showed they were right to be careful. He’s still just 23 (24 at the end of July); he has plenty of time to become the top-of-the-rotation starter we were hoping he’d be.
Before the season we asked:
- If the over/under on Trey’s innings was 150 I’d take the….24.2% of us were pessimistic and right.
- If the over.under on Trey’s ERA is 3.50 I’d take the…..44.4% of us were pessimistic and right again.
- And we asked if Trey would win a Cy Young in his career. 40% of us said yes and I’m still hopeful.























