For the last two baseball seasons, Florida State has been in a vicious cycle of not being able to line up veteran bats with veteran arms.
Last season, the Noles’ top seven pitchers in innings were all juniors or older, making the Seminole arms the calling card that pushed FSU to host its third-straight regional. However, the reason why Florida State did not make it to a third-consecutive Super Regional was the lack of composure at the plate and in the field. Jarrett’s team scored five runs or fewer in three of four games in the Tallahassee regional, as the bats went silent at the worst time.
A year before, a veteran duo of Alex Lodise and Drew Faurot powered FSU at the plate and in the field as Florida State finished one win away from going to Omaha. The offense finished second in the ACC in batting average and ripped over 100 home runs, 24 more homers than in 2026. Unfortunately, the Noles did not have the experience needed on the mound and lacked trustworthy bullpen options, as Florida State struggled to put away games while giving up too many crooked numbers.
But for the upcoming 2027 season, FSU will have age, talent, and experience on both the mound and at the dish for the first time since 2024.
It starts with a bit of luck, especially on the pitching side.
Even though Florida State lost its top-two high school recruits in the MLB Draft, Jarrett and his staff will feel they came out ahead given who was not selected, as RHP John Abraham, RHP Chris Knier, LHP Payton Manca and LHP Cooper Whited return to Tallahassee after not hearing their name called. Starting with Abraham, it was shocking he did not get drafted, and he would have almost certainly signed after his junior season. But, according to Brett Nevitt, he will now turn into a full-time starter, giving Florida State a 1-2 punch atop its rotation alongside transfer LHP Cayden Suchy, who was the 2026 Big East Pitcher of the Year at UConn. On the backend of the rotation, Manca and Whited return for another season and will battle for the Sunday and midweek slots with a host of right-handed transfers, including RHP Isaiah Shayter, who started 14 games for Penn State last season.
In the bullpen, the Noles return a ton of experience, headlined by Knier, who became Micah Posey’s #2 reliever over the course of the 2026 season. LHP Kevin Mebil was also not selected in the MLB Draft and should be in line for an increase in his 20.0 innings pitched a season ago. Further down the line, RHP Cade O’Leary will be expected to take another step after an erratic sophomore season, and RHP Rhett Vaughn looks exceptional on the Cape this summer, with an ERA under one with over 20 innings pitched.
This will be one of the oldest staffs Posey has had in his time in Tallahassee, with a mix of returning production and four transfer pitchers, all with starting experience. The questions in fall camp will be around Abraham’s transition as a starter, who wins the Sunday slot, and who else besides Mebil can be trusted as a bullpen LHP. But the Seminoles will begin the season with a belief that the answers to those questions are in their clubhouse.
On the position-player side, FSU also received welcome draft news with the return of OF Brody DeLamielleure and INF Cal Fisher, but more importantly, Jarrett entered the portal to address some of his wrongs from the 2025 season. Out is Gabe Fraser at shortstop, who entered the transfer portal, and in comes former Indiana SS Cooper Malamazian, who has played in 106 collegiate games with a career .310 batting average, bringing a veteran presence to the infield the Noles desperately lacked a season ago. Jarrett also picked up 1B Nick Barron from Northwestern and 1B/LHP Jackson McKenzie from FAMU, both LHH who hit for power to try and replace the production from Myles Bailey. The rest of the infield should be a battle between returners Cal Fisher, Will Bavaro, Jace Estes, and Texas transfer Callum Early. Both Estes and Early are LHH and will help solve the over-reliance on RHH in the lineup in 2025.
Moving to the outfield, this should once again be a position of strength for Florida State in the 2027 season. John Stuetzer should shift to center field and be one of the most dynamic players in the country after starting 51 games as a freshman and leading the Noles in RBI. As mentioned, DeLamielleure returns and will want to capitalize on a strong second half of his season to boost his draft stock in his redshirt-junior campaign. Most likely, transfer OF Ty Peeples, a LHH, will play left field and is one of the most interesting pickups of the offseason for FSU. Peeples spent his freshman year at Georgia and did not play much, but brings an incredible profile to Dick Howser Stadium. Perfect Game rated Peeples the best outfielder in Georgia in the 2025 recruiting class, and the Toronto Blue Jays drafted him in the 20th round of the 2025 MLB Draft, but he elected to go to campus. Listed at 6’2” and 188 pounds, Peeples can hit for average and power on the left side with above-average athleticism. Jarrett will hope that extended playing time can bring out the best in one of the most talented players on the roster.
It is too early to make any predictions about what this team can be or what its expectations are. But Jarrett assembled a roster where the pieces fit together and used the transfer portal to infuse talent into positions of need, instead of overhauling the whole roster like in previous years. Depending on the way the football season goes, the excitement for the 2027 baseball season will start to build in the fall.