There’s more than one route through October.
Perhaps that’s the ultimate takeaway from what we’ll call the penultimate quadruple-header in Major League Baseball’s playoffs. Day One of the Division Series round saw all four matchups tipping off, and if you’re looking for a hard and fast maxim of What Works and What Is Smart, keep it moving.
Sure, you could pay $60 million a year for a guy to hit just one timely home run, and maybe more to come. Or enter the playoffs with virtually no starting pitchers. Or hand the ball to an ace that’s undergone three major arm surgeries.
All those maneuvers came up aces on Saturday, Oct. 3, when four teams got the jump in this best-of-five round.
Should all four series go at least four games, we’ll do this again Wednesday, when Game 3s in the American League and Game 4s in the National will transpire. For now, let’s isolate some key takeaways from the last guaranteed day of wall-to-wall baseball:
Rays-Yankees looks like the real ALCS

We’re not going to get on a soapbox about the “broken” playoff seeding system. Yeah, it’s not necessarily a great look that the two Division Series matchups will be intra-division battles from the cash-poor Central and the big-boy East.
And perhaps this Tampa Bay Rays-New York Yankees battle deserves the best-of-seven treatment to further separate the two best teams in the game’s best division.
But MLB’s desire to preserve the sanctity of the division title is fairly worthy. It keeps a carrot dangling for good teams to chase throughout September. That the Cleveland Guardians may not truly be “the two seed” isn’t going to kill anybody.
With that said, this Rays-Yankees series will bring the AL playoffs to a premature apex.
You won’t find a finer-played baseball game than the 1-0 one-hitter Tampa Bay threw at New York in Game 1. So clean: There was a well-defined hero and goat, with Drew Rasmussen nearly no-hitting the Yankees until Austin Wells broke it up with a double down the line – and then got thrown out trying to stretch it into a triple.
Rasmussen, famously fighting for his career after three major arm surgeries, got 16 called strikes or whiffs on his changeup, and tied the Yankees up in knots all night. It was jarring seeing a club that scored 18 runs in the two-game wild-card series get held to zero.
The Yankees must rally quickly. Yet they also have undeterred ace Cam Schlittler going in Game 2 Monday, after an off day. He’s aligned to face Freddy Peralta, who pitched much better in Tampa Bay than with the New York Mets.
This series is probably going five games. Every one should be delectable.
The Dodgers are not automatic
Their largesse was on full display in Game 1: Kyle Tucker, the $60 million lockout-inducing slugger, crushed a two-run home run. Tarik Skubal schvitzed through six innings in 100-degree heat. Teoscar Hernández, like Tucker, carried a red-hot September into their playoff lid-lifter and drilled a two-run homer to start the scoring.
Yet a 5-3 win over an Atlanta team that’d be happy to “steal” the game did not suggest this would be a romp through the playoffs. Tanner Scott got got by Ozzie Albies for a two-run, ninth-inning homer.
Skubal got just one swing-and-miss on his 16 fastballs. They hit three homers, but produced no other extra-base hits against an undistinguished stream of Atlanta relievers.
If Chris Sale wakes up Sunday morning feeling spry, there’s a chance this baby is squared 1-1 going back to Atlanta. There’s also a chance the Dodgers assert their dominance, sweep aside the Braves and return to their regularly scheduled programming.
The Sale game, be it in Game 2 or 3, will be an interesting tell: The Dodgers’ aging lineup against the 37-year-old who nonetheless gets it up to 97 mph coming out of his 6-6 frame.
Bullpen games: Don’t try this at home
Goodness, what a show put on by five Chicago White Sox pitchers, starting with Hagen Smith and ending with four sterling innings from erstwhile closer Grant Davis in their 3-0 quieting of Cleveland.
The White Sox are 3-0 in this postseason, turning conventional wisdom on its ear as they remain, largely, a starter-free zone. Great job by them.
Yet starting pitcher paucities are catching up elsewhere.
The Braves used their two guys – Sale and Tyler Mahle – to escape the Phillies’ grip in the wild-card series. And then they were tapped out, starting Dylan Dodd, who gave them three shutout innings before yielding to Victor Mederos and AJ Smith-Shawver.
Who combined to give up all five runs.
Nope, it’s almost impossible to have five relief arms firing at once. Even the great San Diego Padres bullpen found this out.
This was no bullpen game, but lefty Robbie Ray has been hit hard lately and sure enough, recorded just eight outs in Game 1 at Milwaukee. Yuki Matsui, Bradley Rodriguez and Jason Adam all were on point – and then, for one pitch, Adrian Morejon wasn’t.
The All-Star lefty yielded a seventh-inning, go-ahead homer to the Brewers’ William Contreras. Milwaukee survived a shaky night from Jacob Misiorowski. Yet in Game 2, the Padres get good news: Ace Michael King is on turn.
San Diego’s formula appears clear: It must win on nights King and Nick Pivetta start. Because man cannot live on relief arms alone – except, it appears, the White Sox.
Tonnage is fun
A few online grumblers seemed to shake their heads that this four-game festival was pitted against college football. Counterpoint: It’s hard to beat 11 hours of playoff baseball.
Supposedly the big game this week was in Iowa, though reasonable men and women might’ve sniffed out that that was a fraudulent premise. Meanwhile, Game 1s of the Division Series produced a near no-hitter, and four games that qualified as “close-and-late,” including two one-run affairs.
And while they took their medicine Saturday, MLB’s TV logisticians now have it aligned to avoid Big Football during the World Series. Things break right, we can do it all again Wednesday.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: MLB playoffs mega day takeaways: Rays-Yanks is real ALCS, Dodgers not a lock








