One year later, Charlie Coyle trade has been a success for Bruins originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston
The Boston Bruins dismantled their roster ahead of the 2025 NHL trade deadline and dealt away many veteran players — including Brad Marchand, Brandon Carlo, Trent Frederic, and Charlie Coyle, among others — for draft picks and prospects.
It was the right decision at the time as the B’s were on their way to finishing with the league’s fifth-worst record. There was no playoff hockey at TD Garden for the first time since 2016.
The Carlo trade with the Toronto Maple Leafs has been a home run for the Bruins so far. The Coyle trade with the Colorado Avalanche has been a success for Boston, too.
Coyle returns to TD Garden on Thursday for the first time since the trade. He comes back to his hometown rink as a member of the Columbus Blue Jackets, who acquired him in a trade with the Avs last June.
Here’s a recap of the March 7, 2025 trade between the Bruins and Avalanche:
- Bruins received: Casey Mittelstadt, Will Zellers, 2025 second-round pick (Liam Pettersson)
- Avalanche received: Charlie Coyle, 2026 fifth-round pick
How has the Coyle trade benefitted the Bruins so far?
Casey Mittelstadt providing versatility, scoring depth
The NHL player the Bruins got in return for Coyle was forward Casey Mittelstadt. He has tallied 28 points (12 goals, 16 assists) in 47 games this season. He’s on pace to score 15-plus goals for the fourth time in his career. He’s also making a positive impact on Boston’s power play, which ranks third in the league with a 26.9 percent success rate. His 52.2 percent faceoff win rate is a career high as well.
Mittelstadt is a solid middle-six forward who’s versatile enough to play center or wing.
Will Zeller has exciting upside
The Bruins also acquired prospect Will Zellers in the Coyle trade. Zellers was a third-round pick by the Avalanche in 2024. He led the USHL in goals with 44 during the 2024-25 season and earned USHL Player of the Year and Forward of the Year awards.
Zellers has carried that success to the University of North Dakota, where he is having a tremendous freshman season with 26 points (16 goals, 10 assists) in 31 games for the No. 3 ranked team in the nation.
Zellers has exciting goal-scoring ability with the potential to be a top-six wing in the NHL.
The Bruins also received a 2025 second-round pick from the Avalanche in the Coyle deal, which turned out to be the No. 62 overall selection. Boston picked Swedish defenseman Liam Pettersson, who skates really well and has an impressive offensive skill. He’s still a raw talent, but there’s a lot to like about his skill set.
Coyle has been productive in Columbus
How is Coyle playing for the Blue Jackets?
He’s been a dependable two-way center and a strong leader for a young Blue Jackets squad. He has 42 points (15 goals, 27 assists) in 56 games. He had 35 points in 82 games last season, so he’s bounced back offensively and could reach 50-plus points for just the third time in his career.
The verdict
Even though Coyle is playing well, the trade still has worked out pretty well for the Bruins, and there’s a strong possibility that it could get much better depending on how Zellers and Pettersson develop. Mittelstadt is six years younger than Coyle and has proven to be a good fit in the lineup as a versatile forward.
The final grade on the Coyle trade won’t be complete for several years, but the players involved will have a real impact on this season’s playoff race. The Bruins occupy the second wild card playoff spot in the Eastern Conference standings, and one of the teams chasing them four points back is the Blue Jackets.
Thursday’s matchup is the first of three meetings between the Bruins and Blue Jackets over the next seven weeks. Valuable points in the playoffs are at stake in these matchups, and you can bet Coyle and Mittelstadt will have their say in the outcome.