Hey, Babe! Phillies and Yankees share some fun connections originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia
The New York Yankees visit Citizens Bank Park for a weekend series beginning Friday night.
It doesn’t matter where they go — Tampa Bay, Boston, Houston, Miami — it’s always an event when the Yankees come to your town. From The Babe to those 27 World Series titles, they’re the most storied franchise in pro sports. So, it’ll be exciting to have them in Philadelphia these next few days. Both the Yankees and Phillies are locked in tight playoff races. It’s an important series for both clubs.
Though they play in different leagues, and though the Yankees can boast about having 25 more World Series championships than the Phillies, the two teams share some interesting history and common threads.
Let’s look at a few of them, just for fun:
AT THE HELM
Three straight Phillies managers, including current skipper Don Mattingly, have deep Yankee bloodlines. As a player, Mattingly was one of the most beloved Yankees ever. He played 14 seasons for the club, won an MVP award, a batting title and made six All-Star teams. His No. 23 is retired.
Mattingly succeeded Rob Thomson, who initially came to the Phillies as a bench coach under Gabe Kapler after 28 years working as a big-league coach, minor-league manager and farm director for the Yankees.
Thomson became Phillies manager in 2022 when Joe Girardi was fired. Girardi won three World Series as a player with the Yankees. He skippered the club for 10 years and beat the Phillies in the 2009 World Series.
Phillies pitching coach Caleb Cotham pitched for Girardi’s Yankees in 2015. Girardi was influential in bringing him to Philadelphia.
MR. OCTOBER
Hall of Famer Reggie Jackson became synonymous with the Yankees when he homered in three straight at-bats to help them win the 1977 World Series.
Reggie grew up just outside of Philadelphia, in Wyncote, and was a star athlete at Cheltenham High School. He attended his first big-league game in 1956 at Connie Mack Stadium, but he wasn’t there to see the Phillies. He was there to see the visiting Brooklyn Dodgers and his idol, Jackie Robinson.
“We sat in the left field bleachers, 50 cents, my dad took us,” Jackson told us in 2022. “We ate popcorn and rooted for the Dodgers because they had Black players. I wasn’t a Phillies fan until they got Dick Allen. I rooted for him and, of course, I played against him. In my mind, he’s a Hall of Famer.”
Allen was finally elected to the Hall of Fame in December 2024.
1950 WORLD SERIES
The Yankees won five straight World Series from 1949 to 1953. Their second in that stretch came against the 1950 Phillies, the Whiz Kids, who made the World Series for the first time since 1915.
The Yankees won the first two games in Philadelphia by scores of 1-0 and 2-1 and went on to sweep the Phils in four games. Joe DiMaggio famously homered off Robin Roberts in the top of the 10th to give the Yankees the lead in Game 2 at Shibe Park.
It wasn’t unusual for players to sneak a smoke in between innings in those days. Legend has it that DiMaggio asked a young Philadelphia cop to hold his cigarette before going to the plate in the 10th. That young cop was named Frank Rizzo and he eventually became Philadelphia’s mayor.
2009 WORLD SERIES
Fifty-nine years after their first World Series meeting in 1950, the Phils and Yanks battled again in the 2009 World Series. Cliff Lee decided to skip the police-escorted team bus and take a cab to Yankee Stadium for Game 1. He got stuck in gridlock traffic and jumped on a subway. He followed fans in Yankee jerseys to the stadium and arrived less than two hours before first pitch, much to the relief of team officials who were worried he wouldn’t make it. The always-cool Lee then went out and struck out 10 in a walk-free complete-game win.
Chase Utley hit five home runs in the series but the Phils lost in six games. After the final loss, Phillies owner John Middleton famously told Ryan Howard, “I want my (bleeping) trophy back.” All these years later, the quote still applies.
FREE AGENT BATTLE
After the 2009 season, the Phillies acquired Roy Halladay in a trade with Toronto and shipped Cliff Lee to Seattle.
A year later, Lee became a free agent.
The Phillies, Yankees and Texas Rangers all entered the bidding.
The Yankees offered the most money, something in the neighborhood of $140 million over six years, and were willing to go higher. But Lee chose to sign with the Phillies for five years and $120 million. That ticked off the Yankees, who were used to getting what they wanted.
Lee had initially been angry that the Phillies traded him away after the 2009 season, but Scott Proefrock, then a Phillies assistant general manager under Ruben Amaro Jr., worked hard to rebuild the relationship. Lee’s wife also had a say in the decision to come to Philadelphia. Yankee fans had given her an earful in the Bronx when he pitched for Texas in the 2010 postseason and she didn’t want to go there.
THE BABE A PHILLIE?
It could have happened.
Way back in 1914, Babe Ruth was a teenage phenom with his hometown Baltimore Orioles of the International League. Jack Dunn, who ran the Orioles, offered Ruth and two other players to the Phillies for $19,000. Phillies owner William Baker scoffed at the offer, saying he wouldn’t pay that much for the entire International League. In fairness, Philadelphia Athletics owner/manager Connie Mack also passed on a chance to acquire Ruth. The rest, as they say, is history.
Baker was a bit of a cheapskate. A year after he passed on Ruth, Baker’s Phillies made the World Series but were beaten by the Boston Red Sox, who were shrewd enough to take Dunn up on his offer but foolish enough to turn around and sell Ruth to the Yankees in 1919.
Some 106 years after Baker passed on The Babe and said he wouldn’t pay $19,000 for the entire International League, another Phillies owner mentioned Ruth. Angered by a 2020 media report that claimed the team was dangling ace Zack Wheeler in trade talks, Middleton said, “If they offered me Babe Ruth, I wouldn’t trade him.”
SCHILLING SHINES
The Phillies were awful in 1997. They finished 68-94, tied with the Chicago Cubs for the worst record in the NL.
The Yankees, by contrast, won 96 games that season. They won the World Series the year before, starting a run of four titles in five years.
Fed up with losing and fired-up for a chance to face the star-studded lineup, Phillies ace Curt Schilling turned a Labor Day start against the Yanks that year into his personal World Series. A crowd of 50,895 turned out at Veterans Stadium (the Phils averaged just 18,403 that year) and saw Schilling strike out 16 over eight walk-free innings in a 5-1 win.
High-priced flop Hideki Irabu pitched for the Yankees that day. The Phillies tagged him for five runs in three innings. After leaving the game, Irabu smashed a sprinkler head in the visiting clubhouse. How rude.
THE PURSUIT OF PETTITTE
Andy Pettitte struggled through a difficult season with the Yankees in 1999. Yankees boss George Steinbrenner ordered general manager Brian Cashman to trade the left-hander before the July deadline.
Phillies general manager Ed Wade wanted Pettitte badly. He built a package around pitcher Adam Eaton, outfielder Reggie Taylor and others.
Optimism for a deal was so high that Phillies pitcher Carlton Loewer offered to give up his No. 46 for Pettitte. The Phillies presented the best offer, but Pettitte ended up staying put as Steinbrenner told Cashman to pull the pitcher off the table less than an hour before the deadline. The Phillies front office put a lot of hours into trying to pull off that deal. There were a lot of disappointed folks when it didn’t happen.
CASHMAN TO PHILLIES?
Brian Cashman is in his 29th season as Yankees general manager. It is one of the most remarkable runs in sports history, especially considering the high-pressure market he works in and the man he once answered to.
But in the fall of 2005, Cashman strongly considered leaving the Yankees. His contract was set to run out on October 31 of that year. He’d grown tired of the politics, the backstabbing and the drama of the Yankees’ dueling front offices in the Bronx and Tampa. The Phillies had just fired Wade. Cashman had the Phillies in his sights. He even privately mentioned it to some old college buddies who’d grown up as Phillies fans.
“I had to weigh what was next and the Phillies, obviously, had an opening,” Cashman told us at the time.
Ultimately, Cashman had a meeting of the minds with George Steinbrenner. He received assurances that things would change and his authority would be respected. He signed a three-year contract extension with the Yankees as the Phillies hired Pat Gillick.
“I think the Phillies hired the most qualified general manager,” Cashman told us in November 2005. “You can line Pat up with anybody in the game and he might stand tallest of all. I believe I would have gotten an interview, though it would have been tough to compete with Pat Gillick.”
A STAR IS BORN
In March 2004, 20-year-old Cole Hamels was beginning his second season in pro ball. He had made just 18 starts, all at the Single A level, when the Phillies decided to take a peek at him in a spring-training game against the Yankees in Tampa. The game was carried live on ESPN. John Kruk was part of the broadcast team.
Hamels, the Phillies’ top pick in the 2002 draft, did not disappoint. In fact, he dropped jaws. He struck out Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez and Tony Clark, all on changeups, in the fifth inning. From that moment on, Hamels seemed destined for the stardom that arrived in October 2008 when he was NLCS and World Series MVP.