
I’m not going to completely pivot my articles this offseason – I still want the Cardinals to try to win and will come up with possible ways to do that, however – not to keep going back to our conversation with Derrick Goold last week – knowing the Cardinals probably won’t look at 2027 and judge it by wins and losses, I feel like it would be appropriate to look at a different approach to the offseason as well. If the Cardinals aren’t going to try to improve the team and instead focus on the future, trading players close to free agency would certainly make sense.
And sadly nobody makes more sense than Alec Burleson in that regard. Burleson is in an interesting spot. He may have just had a career year and we don’t know it. Or he hasn’t reached his peak yet. Or what he showed last year is entirely what he is and we can expect that for a few more seasons. Any of these outcomes would be entirely unsurprising. He’s also simultaneously a very reliable and stable player. So when I say he may have just had a career year, if that ends up being true, it’s because he’s about a 2 WAR player instead. And if he hasn’t reached his peak, that likely means 4 WAR is his peak, not MVP contender (notwithstanding that he actually got an MVP vote)
If this were 2002, I’d say trade him absolutely. There is very little chance he repeats his RBI season. He does appear to change his approach based on if there are men on. When nobody is on base, he has a .228 ISO and hit 17 homers. With men on base, it’s a .163 ISO. But, his BABIP was rather extreme. He had a .423 BABIP with runners in scoring position. That seems unlikely to repeat. Most teams will not up their price based on his RBI, so it seems more likely you’d get fair value than a haul.
What is Burleson worth on the market? Let’s calculate. MLB Trade Rumors calculates his 2027 salary at $8.3 million. It will be his second year in arbitration. Let’s say his last year in arbitration is $14 million. That means over the next two years, he’ll be paid $22.3 million. What will his projection be? Steamer projects 2 WAR over 570 PAs. Don’t want to be a biased fan, but I think that’s low. I think I’m going to hang my hat on his xwOBA a little bit, because it was .374, which greatly exceeded his actual wOBA of .353. With a career .291 BABIP, it makes sense why Steamer would project a .294 BABIP, I feel like the contact quality suggests either a higher BABIP in a projection is reasonable.
I also think the PAs is a bit low, which may be why the Fangraphs depth charts section has him with 609 PAs across 141 games. While he had just 546 PAs in 2025, it did come in 139 games. In 2025, 7 of 12 appearances that came with two or less plate appearances were in March and April and all 12 came before the All-Star break. So from a health perspective, he’s a fairly likely bet to appear in 141 games. With the increased games comes 2.3 WAR. I think it’s entirely reasonable to raise that to 2.5 WAR basically because of the xwOBA, which I doubt is factored into the Steamer projection at all. Some version of that might be in ZiPS though. Plus, any team trading for him probably sees him as a 2.5 or better player anyway, and that’s probably how a team will have to see him for the Cardinals to trade him in the first place. I could actually go higher, but I’m trying to keep it in the realm of projection-based rather than hope.
Since I’m slightly fudging the numbers for 2027, at least based on a projection I actually do have (this might actually be low whenever ZiPS releases its numbers), I’m going to have to stick with the half a win decline for his second season. So that’s 4.5 WAR while getting paid $22.3 million. In other words, his trade value, hypothetically speaking, is about $23 million in prospect value and/or established MLB value.
If you were expecting a haul for Burleson, sadly you won’t get one. This isn’t even enough for a top 100 prospect. Fangraphs prospect values are not updated, and won’t be until they release the team lists, so I don’t think I can come up with proposals from other teams that might be realistic. What I can give you is – and I actually think might be more informative – is a Cardinals package equivalent. Basically, if the Cardinals were trading for Burleson, what kind of prospects would they have to give up to get Burleson? Based on the prospects I can come up with in the Cardinals’ system can maybe help you know whether or not you think the return would be worth trading him. Because just about everyone reading this is significantly more knowledgable about the Cardinals’ prospects than any collection of names I could come up with.
Unlike my usual hypothetical deals, I can use any prospect I want. We’re looking for the best versions of these prospects, so it makes sense to present the best possible version of these deals. It wouldn’t make any sense for me to hoard a prospect in a trade that could physically never happen. If the Cardinals trade Burleson, they will want the best possible 45 FV prospect. And the Cardinals certainly don’t have to trade Burleson, so fine if you don’t want to give me that prospect, you aren’t getting him.
Well if we’re trading Burleson, I think I want the centerpiece to be a hitter. I’m kind of satisfied with where the pitching depth is and a lot of the position player depth is farther away than ideal. ORSTLcards highlighted this in his recent article. In addition, to state the obvious, but the Cardinals are trading away a key piece of the offense, so it’d be weird not to get offense back.
So in light of this, my centerpiece of the trade is a 45+ FV, which comprises most of the $23 million. And amusingly, I may have actually come up with a trade people actually want because it just so happens the Cardinals do have an enticing, probably 45+ FV prospect in their system at a position of need and that trading the equivalent of that guy would give the Cardinals two chances at a good CF: Tai Peete. I’m guessing that he’s 45+ by the way. He was 40+ last year, so he’s at least a 45 now.
The second part of this trade is harder. It’s either a 40 FV hitter or 40 FV pitcher. You have two options here – you can go lottery ticket or you can go close to the majors, but not very high potential. For position players, the Cardinals really don’t have any of the latter. Maybe that will change with the update, but anybody who is a 40 FV hitter is not particularly close to the majors. Cesar Prieto was, but I don’t think he is anymore. I’m not really interested in a likely bench player though as the second piece, Cardinals are covered in that area.
Pitching-wise though, it’s a bit more appealing to get someone close to the majors who is largely expected to go to the bullpen. The best and closest version of this kind of prospect is probably Brian Curley. An older draftee acquired in the Lars Nootbaar trade, he struck out 29.5% of hitters in High A, and then wasn’t very good in AA, but it was his first pro season. According to Fangraphs, he has three pitches with the potential to be above average, but they do not think highly of his command. Which is interesting, because walks were not actually his problem in AA. But command is more than not walking guys. I’m not interested in the 40 FV pitching prospect who is far away.
The 40 FV hitting prospect who is far away, however, might have actually potential. But they are incredibly unlikely to achieve that potential. But this kind of prospect is certainly the kind you grab if you want to make a trade look really, really lopsided in the future and not for the team getting Burleson. Hello, Emanuel Luna, come aboard the train. He played in 9 fantastic games in the DSL. He will be 18 next year. So those are your offers. If you were receiving this prospect in return, and keep in mind, you have an attachment to these prospects, so the Tai Peete of another organization will be someone you will be more objective about – would you take a trade like this?
Alec Burleson for Tai Peete and Brian Curley/Emanuel Luna
Who needs a 1B?
How robust of a market will there be for him? Easy way to figure it out is how many teams would be interested. I think most teams will acquire him wanting him to play 1B or DH. If they have a massive amount of money invested in their 1B and reasonable options to play DH, I can’t see them wanting Burleson.
Out
Athletics (Nick Kurtz/Brent Rooker), Orioles (Pete Alonso), Red Sox (they just got Jake Bauers), Astros (they’re paying too much for Christian Walker to be almost average, plus someone has to DH of Carlos Correa, Yordan Alvarez, and Isaac Paredes), Angels (not really trying to win and still going with Nolan Schanuel), Mariners (Josh Naylor just got a big deal and is very similar to Burly), Rays (Yandy Diaz and Jonathan Aranda are still here, and to trade for escalating contract is not Rays at all), Jays (they have so much money tied up in 1B/DH between Anthony Santander and Vladmir Guerrero Jr.)
Cubs (ignoring the in-division aspect, Michael Busch and they don’t actually have anywhere for Pedro Ramirez to play), Reds (in-divison + Sal Stewart), Dodgers (Freddie Freeman + Shohei Ohtani), Marlins (I just think Owen Cassie/Kyle Stowers/Griffin Conine and Burleson on the same team makes no sense, and they’re don’t really trade for escalating salaries), Phillies (Kyle Schwarber/Bruce Harper make it hard to see a fit unless they want him in the outfield), Pirates (I think they’re committed to Ryan O’Hearn and Spencer Horwitz, both are left-handed and restricted to 1B and DH), Giants (Bryce Eldridge and Rafael Devers)
Probably out
Tigers (Spencer Torkelson isn’t good, but they seem committed to him plus I don’t think they’re giving up on Kerry Carpenter), Royals (same for Vinnie Pasquatino/Salvador Perez DH’d 82 games last year), Yankees (I know they’ve been thrown as an option purely because of park, but Ben Rice and Luis Garcia make it seem pretty unlikely), Rockies (they could use Burleson, but also they’re not trying to win), Brewers (I mean Burleson could replace Bauers, but this strikes me as very unlikely)
Maybe
Guardians (would be unlike them with Kyle Manzardo and Jo Adell at DH, but neither of them are actually good), Braves (if they are okay with him DH’ing, where they appear weak), Padres (Gavin Sheets is not great and Luis Campusano had what looks like an unsustainably great year with the bat… but maybe they’re okay with these options), Nationals (Andres Chapparo had a great year in half a season, and they have 4 young outfielders that have to play, but also Chapparo probably isn’t going to be good, so if they want to be proactive, they make sense. Chapparo is also right-handed)
Need
Twins (current 1B is… Royce Lewis?), Rangers (Jake Burger/Justin Foscue is their 1B/DH right now on Roster Resource), DBacks (Tim Tawa is projected 1B at the moment. Below average hitter last year), Mets (Jared Young and Jorge Polanco are projected 1B/DH – that’s really bad!)
Of the teams, Diamondbacks and Rangers actually seem like they might be trying to win. Most of the maybe group either isn’t trying to win or is generally pretty cheap, but actually would get a player like Burleson if either of those things wasn’t true. So one of them could be realistic. Market is okay, not necessarily screaming out overpay for Burleson though.
Book Corner
I am making progress on Crime and Punishment. I have read five of the six parts, so I’m hoping to be done by Thursday. The biggest difficulty is the long paragraphs. The translation I am reading is trying to stay true to the words of Fyodor Dostoevsky, but splitting up the paragraphs would make it so much easier to read, it’d be worth it in my opinion. I mean my eyes start glazing over when I get to the second page of the same paragraph and notice that the paragraph doesn’t seem to end on that same page.
Also I don’t know if this is just how Russians speak in the 19th century or a Dostoevsky thing , but man every character goes on these long tangents and I don’t think he does a good enough job of distinguishing them from each other. They all sound like they could be from the same person. I think the characterization of the characters is distinct to be clear, but sometimes when they talk, they talk the same way. A meandering, over-explaining, formal lecture that never ends. I know we have short attention spans, but when we talk to each other, one person doesn’t typically talk for five minutes without the other person saying a word, and that happens all the time in this book.
Part five almost lost me. Not to the point of stopping, but just in terms of “why are you doing this to me?” He just begins part five from a completely different point of view to a character we have barely read about and I am reading this section and thinking “I don’t care about this, why are we making this diversion?” He sort of gets me back, because I learn why. And then the ending weirdly turns full soap opera? A random death out of nowhere and then a genuine “Surprise, but I actually heard everything you said somehow.” I know soap operas weren’t a thing then but it’s still jarring as hell when nothing before this has been soap opera-like at all.
I will finish Part Six and give my final thoughts on Thursday.














