Welcome to SB Nation Reacts, a survey of fans across Major League Baseball. Throughout the year we ask questions of the most plugged-in Yankees fans and fans across the country. Sign up here to participate in the weekly emailed surveys.
July has nearly all but come and gone, and the Major League Baseball Trade Deadline sits exactly one week away. It’s still a little odd to me personally to see it land on August 3rd, but that’s what the league decided before the beginning of 2026, so that’s just how it is.
Honestly, in a muddled season like 2026 to date, it’s probably for the best to give teams as much time as possible to determine if they think they’re true contenders or pretenders. The league’s respective Wild Card races are flush with mediocrity and even some division leaders are barely above .500. Do not take this for throwing stones in a glass house, however; the Yankees are certainly lacking in certain areas of their team and most desperately need captain Aaron Judge to return to health by September 1st at the absolute earliest.
In the meantime, the Yankees at least have another week to consider the best possible external options to improve their roster. It’s a tricky game, and as always, it takes two to tango. Even if you want your team to get Player X and they put forth the public’s consensus best offer, they’re not a lock to land him. The selling club is well within its rights to decline if their own internal valuations have a different opinion.
The Yankees will look to make a move, but what position should be their greatest priority? This was the topic of last week’s Reacts survey. The results are below.*
*Keep in mind that this poll ran before news broke of rumored catching addition Shea Langeliers’ possible season-ending injury and Cody Bellinger’s hamstring strain.
Yankees fans are fairly at the limit with the current catching plans. Despite a homer over the weekend, Austin Wells has been a colossal disappointment this year. Yankees catchers have combined for a .185/.268/.283 triple slash in 2026, which FanGraphs rates as a 56 wrC+, the third-worst mark in baseball. There desperately needs to be some improvement there, hence the overwhelming 74-percent majority voting for “catcher” in this survey. Colorado’s Hunter Goodman, Minnesota’s Ryan Jeffers, and Cincinnati’s Tyler Stephenson are all possible options who we’ve profiled as possible trade targets.
Of course, it’s not as though fans are solely focused on the men behind the plate. A common response to the Feed poll was that there were numerous areas to improve.
One possible counterpoint was raised by ConorGallogly, who noted that there was reason to be optimistic about some degree of a Wells rebound. Through his first three seasons in the majors (937 plate appearances), he was a 100 wRC+ hitter. Could he really be a true-talent 55 wRC+ now? Some uncertainty about that is understandable. And the Yankees’ left side of the infield has been a weakness with Anthony Volpe, José Caballero, Ryan McMahon, and Amed Rosario all leaving plenty to be desired at shortstop and third base.
The last sentence of the comment, however? That is also true. Wells undoubtedly has “just been so bad.”
Another point raised was that general manager Brian Cashman could try to improve a relative strength and add a starting pitcher. At the very least, it’s hard not to at least consider a package for two-time defending Cy Young Award winner Tarik Skubal, who would be the best name on the market if the disappointing Tigers made him available.
Imagine Skubal with Cam Schlittler, Gerrit Cole, and Max Fried in a playoff rotation? Holy moly. Again, it’s probably a pipe dream, but why not dream big?
Another pitcher who might be out of reach but still fascinating is elite Padres closer Mason Miller, who could be on the market for the second year in a row. David Bednar, Fernando Cruz, Brett Headrick, and even Paul Blackburn have provided some great innings of late relief, but there’s certainly a sentiment that the Yankees could use at least one more reliable reliever to make the middle relief more palatable. And it doesn’t have to be an addition who slots in there; instead, it could be a jewel like Miller, who pushes everyone down the pecking order.
Someone like Miller’s teammate Adrian Morejon might be more likely, though.
We’ll see what the Yankees end up doing. And stay tuned for the next Reacts survey, when we’ll delve into the Yankees’ catching options on the market! I agree that some move there is most likely (and the greatest need).
These survey results are sponsored by FanDuel.