The most memorable part of Carlos Rodón’s second start back after offseason elbow surgery was a wild pitch he followed with an even worse throw back to the plate.
Access the Yankees beat like never before
Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Greg Joyce about the inside buzz on the Yankees.
Try it freeA pair of runs scored on the play and helped spur the Mets to a 6-3 win over the Yankees at Citi Field.
The Yankees, by virtue of their solid start to the season — backed in no small part by the rotation — can afford to wait as Rodón finds his form.
But through his first two outings, the left-hander has been far from sharp and it cost them on Saturday, as they lost for the sixth time in their last eight games.
“I’ve got to be better,” Rodón said. “Especially with two outs.”
He has struggled with his command, walking three in just 3 ²/₃ innings on Saturday and in both the third and fourth innings, he retired the first two batters only to fail to finish off the frame before allowing the Mets to score.
Rodón called his performance “pretty inconsistent … I got two outs and the inning unraveled.”
In the third, he struck out Brett Baty and Luis Torrens before Carson Benge doubled to right.
Walks to the slumping Bo Bichette and the ever-dangerous Juan Soto followed.
Then things got wild.
Rodón airmailed a pitch to Mark Vientos. The ball bounced off the brick wall behind home plate toward the lefty, who caught it and compounded his mistake by trying to throw out Benge at home.
His toss to Austin Wells was also wild, leaving the catcher no chance. The error allowed Bichette to score from second base and advanced Soto to third.
- CHECK OUT THE LATEST MLB STANDINGS AND YANKEES STATS
Suddenly, the one-run Yankees lead became a 2-1 deficit.
“That was a stupid play,’’ Rodón said. “I tried to make a superhero play. That’s one I’ve got to eat.”
Rodón got Vientos to ground out to end the inning. However, a two-out walk to Austin Slater in the fourth extended the inning, allowing Baty to hammer a 111 mph double over Aaron Judge in right field, driving in Slater to make it 3-1.
Again, the fact that Rodón has been rusty in some of his minor league rehab starts and his first two with the Yankees after having surgery to remove loose bodies and shave down a bone spur in his left elbow isn’t a disaster.
But until he flashes the form he showed in 2025, questions will linger as the Yankees also wait for Gerrit Cole to return from the Tommy John surgery he underwent during spring training of last year.
The fast start to the season the Yankees got off to, as well as the mediocre state of the rest of the American League, have given them the luxury to survive without Rodón and Cole.
- WinCraft insulated can coolers
- Team Effort driver head cover
- 47 Brand adjustable cap
- Customizable jersey
- Logo fleece blanket
- 14-ounce sculpted relief coffee mug
Cam Schlittler has emerged as a Cy Young candidate in his first full season in the majors.
And Ryan Weathers and Will Warren have also pitched well.
But with Max Fried out with a left elbow bone bruise, the Yankees will be looking to Rodón to carry some of the load.
They entered Saturday with the third-best rotation ERA in the majors (3.09), trailing only Atlanta and Tampa Bay.
The Yankees might be able to point to Rodón retiring eight of the first nine batters he faced on Saturday — and striking out six in the outing — but it wasn’t enough to beat a Mets team that entered in disarray, after losing Clay Holmes to a fractured leg on Friday.