The Red Sox had more hits than the Blue Jays, more walks than the Blue Jays, more than double the opportunities with runners in scoring position than the Blue Jays, and yet lost an uncompetitive 6-1 snoozefest to the Blue Jays.
Despite numerous chances to take an early lead against Dylan Cease, who was struggling to find the strike zone throughout his unimpressive 108 pitch outing that lasted just five innings, Boston managed to score zero runs before he left the mound. That’s of course because the 2026 Red Sox are running an absolute masterclass on how to lose baseball games. In fact, losing might be the only thing they’re truly great at.
Tonight’s special twist was a 1-12 effort with runners in scoring position (and the one didn’t even leave the infield) that came attached with 13 men left on base. Their only run came on a Jarren Duran solo homer, which is worth mentioning because it also came on the only one of Duran’s five plate appearance where there wasn’t anybody on base. Great timing as always from this offense!
It’s not just that this team stinks, it’s that they’re consistently less then the sum of their parts. They don’t know how to pick each other up, string competitive at bats together, get clutch hits when trailing late in games, or do anything remotely competent for more than one or two days in row. Most every halfway decent stat line is emptier than it looks, and the team is on pace to lose more games at Fenway Park than any Red Sox team in history!
Before the game tonight, Craig Breslow said they’re not giving up on the season and that their focus is still more on trying to win games each night. Well, teams that are trying to urgently win games to save their season generally aren’t allowing a washed up Masataka Yoshida to remain on their roster, much less bat leadoff. They’re also not using Mickey Gasper — a career sub .200 hitter with just two home runs in 227 plate appearances — to pinch hit as the tying run in the eighth inning.
The product is just so embarrassing and underwhelming, and it’s almost impossible to believe it’s gotten this bad before we’ve even hit the summer solstice.
Three Studs
Jarren Duran: Went 2-5, scored and produced the only Red Sox run with his eighth inning solo blast, and he also had the only Red Sox hit with a runner in scoring position, even if it was a lucky infield knock.
Connor Wong: Was on base all three times going 2-2 with a walk before getting pinch hit for in favor of Mickey Gasper in the eighth inning. If I’m Wong, I’m not at all pleased about getting called back there.
Greg Weissert: Score one for Over The Monster’s own Jacob Roy, who wrote about Weissert starting to show signs of life earlier today. Tonight he was the only Red Sox pitcher to not allow a run.
Five Duds
Willson Contreras: Horrible game for the usually productive Contreras. 0-4 with four strikeouts. Probably not a mystery the team felt extra dead tonight with his bat going silent.
Masataka Yoshida: Went 1-5 at DH from the leadoff spot and continues to hit weak ground balls almost exclusively. Provides zero spark at the top of the lineup.
Caleb Durbin: It was an unlucky 0-4 at he didn’t strike out and got bit by two strong catches in centerfield, but an 0-4 night is an 0-4 night, especially when you’re batting .190 on the season.
Chad Tracy: In general, I’m willing to give Chad Tracy a pretty long rope with the mess he’s inherited, but he can’t be pinch hitting Mickey Gasper there in the eighth inning. He needs to be batting less often in high leverage situations late in games, not more.
Payton Tolle: Unfortunately that’s two clunkers in a row for him. It probably wouldn’t have mattered anyway tonight with this sorry excuse for an offense, but the Red Sox are now 3-10 in his 13 career starts.
Play of the game:
Every single Red Sox at bat with runners in scoring position, but I’ll spare you the long conveyor belt of gory videos.