Pittsburgh Penguins general manager/president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas met with the media on Tuesday for his end-of-season press conference, and he discussed a wide range of significant topics.
At the top of the list: Evgeni Malkin’s future with the Penguins, where the Penguins currently stand in the NHL with the progress they made this season, and what they need to do next in order to get where they want to be.
Also, speaking of Dubas, the finalists for the NHL’s general manager of the year award were announced on Tuesday and Dubas was not among the top-three vote-getters. There are a lot of people in hockey that simply do not like him. This seems to be pretty significant confirmation of that, because that result just seems weird.
But that is another discussion for another day.
Let’s get into the big topics as it relates to the Penguins.
On the Evgeni Malkin situation
Dubas gave the best possible answer that he could have possibly given here.
He praised Malkin, understands his place in the history of the franchise and the league, said all of the right things about him, acknowledged that he is not blocking anybody if he returns, and flat out said “we would love to have him back.”
Also said he had a great exit interview with him and that he is still talking to Malkin’s agent to make the contract work.
My takeaway on this: He is either doing really good PR for himself in the event that Malkin leaves, or a new contract is inevitable.
I feel like the latter is probably the most likely.
But you can’t really rule out the former. Dubas isn’t dumb. He knows how to deal with the media and how to play the game publicly. By shifting the onus onto Malkin he positioned himself to say, “hey, we wanted him back, it just didn’t work.” He might still very well want to move on, but he also knows in doing so that would always be attached to his tenure here, and if it did not work out …. well … that is the kind of thing that can linger.
Now, having said that, I will repeat, Dubas isn’t dumb. He also has to know that playing that sort of PR game with a franchise icon probably won’t go over well with anybody.
So I am still leaning toward the “Malkin will be back next season” side of this.
On where the Penguins are right now
Dubas’ assessment of the 2025-26 Penguins is that they were a good team, and at times flirted with being a “very good” team. But he also acknowledged that while they did make some progress, they were not good enough, and are not anywhere close to being a contender. He even mentioned that while watching the second-round of the playoffs he has openly wondered if they would be able to compete with the top teams in the league.
He has repeatedly said that his goal here is not just about making the playoffs, but building a contender-worthy team that can compete for championships.
In his view, they are clearly not at that level.
That is also not an unfair take. They were good this season. But even as they won more games and got into the playoffs everybody still knew they were at least a step below the likes of Colorado and Carolina.
Dubas specifically referenced the Hurricanes being the class of the division and said at the present time the Penguins are not even close to them.
On what they need to do to get there
Dubas seemed most bothered by how much the Penguins give up defensively, and that has to be a focus before they can get back to the level they want to play at.
That was clearly the Achilles heel of the Penguins all season.
While they finished near the top of the league in pretty much every major offensive category, from goals scored, to power play, to scoring chances to expected goals, they were significantly worse when it came to what they allowed going back the other way.
During 5-on-5 play they were 22nd in goals against, 20th in expected goals against, 23rd in scoring chances against and 22nd in high-danger scoring chances against.
Clearly that is not good enough.
Dubas talks about Penguins as “destination” team for players “with some control over their situation.”
To me, this is the most significant thing that Dubas said on Tuesday, and might indicate the type of players he is going to be looking at this offseason.
He specifically referenced “players in their mid-to-late 20s.”
It does not take a lot of imagination to try and figure out the type of players he might be referencing here when he talks about that age range, and players with “some control” over their situation.
No-trade clauses.
Restricted free agents.
Players that might want out of their current situation.
It also seems to indicate he has little interest in the unrestricted free agent market.
Dubas has been extremely aggressive in roster movement since taking over the Penguins, and it does not require much overthinking to guess that we might be in for a hectic offseason.