
If you’ve been around here a few years, you might know that I’m a Hall of Fame junkie. That makes today a big day on the calendar for me: the Baseball Writers Association of America has revealed the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot.
Next week, I’m going to give you my hypothetical ballot, were I given a chance to vote, so I’ll go more in-depth on those players then. Today, I’ll do a quick rundown of everyone on the ballot, both new and returning players, and give a quick thought about their chances of getting into the Hall of Fame this year.
A quick reminder of the rules: a player must get 75% of the votes to gain enshrinement. If they fail to receive 75% in 10 years, or they get less than 5% of the vote, they fall off the ballot.
New Players
Jake Arrieta, Starting Pitcher
Arrieta pitched for 12 years in a career that began in Baltimore but peaked with the Cubs in Chicago. In 2015, he won the Cy Young Award when he went 22-6 with a 1.77 ERA and led the league in shutouts (3), hits per nine (5.9), and homers per nine (0.4). He was particularly good after the All-Star break: Arrieta allowed only nine earned runs over 107 1/3 innings (0.75 ERA) in the second half, an MLB record for a starting pitcher post-All-Star break. While he had a few other solid seasons, none was anywhere close to 2015, and he finished his career with 115 wins and a 104 ERA+, and 22.7 bWAR. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Jay Bruce, Outfielder
Brewers fans will remember Bruce well—it felt like he was constantly hitting homers against them. And it’s kind of true: 35 of Bruce’s 319 career homers came against the Brewers, 12 more than against any other opponent. Bruce was a fairly one-dimensional player but hit over 300 homers and made three All-Star teams. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Asdrúbal Cabrera, Infielder
Cabrera’s best seasons came in Cleveland, where he spent the first seven-and-a-half years of his career and made his only two All-Star teams. At his best, Cabrera had some real pop—he hit 25 homers in 2011 and won a Silver Slugger. But he was a mediocre-at-best defensive infielder, so most of his 30 career bWAR came from offensive value. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Starlin Castro, Infielder
Ah, another Brewer nemesis. Castro joined the Cubs just after his 20th birthday, and in his second season, at 21, he led the league in hits, made the All-Star team, and got down-ballot MVP votes. He made three more All-Star teams over the next six years, though the last of those was when he was a Yankee; Castro wasn’t a very good defensive shortstop and he had a career walk rate of just 5.1%, so advanced stats aren’t especially kind to him. Still, he had 1,722 career hits, a big number. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Wade Davis, Relief Pitcher
Davis was a mega prospect as a starting pitcher, reaching as high as #17 on Baseball America’s top prospect list prior to the 2008 season. But he wasn’t great as a starter when he debuted with Tampa Bay in the early 2010s, and in his third full season, they moved him to the bullpen, where he was really good. After that season, he was included in the massive James Shields/Wil Myers swap with the Royals; Kansas City tried him as a starter, too, but it went very badly. In 2014 they moved him to the bullpen, and for the next four years Davis was an absolute Hall-of-Fame level reliever: in 244 games he had a 1.45 ERA. He shone brightest at the biggest moments, too: in 12 postseason appearances in 2014, he allowed one earned run and struck out 20 in 14 1/3 innings as the Royals won the AL. The next season, when the Royals finished the job, Davis didn’t allow a run and struck out 18 in 10 2/3 innings. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but he was at the right level for a few years.
Brett Gardner, Outfielder
Gardner spent his whole 14-year career with the Yankees. He was, according to OPS+, an exactly league-average hitter during his career (100 OPS+, 1,470 hits, 139 homers in 1,688 games) but was good on the basepaths (274 stolen bases) and was arguably one of the best defensive corner outfielders of all time. Because of that combination of things—average hitting, great defense, good baserunning—he accrued a lot of career value, with 44.3 WAR via Baseball Reference. (FanGraphs doesn’t value his defense as highly and he only has 37.3 WAR via their version of the stat.) Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but he might get a handful of votes.
Jon Lester, Starting Pitcher
Finally, we’ve reached a player who we really need to discuss. Lester pitched 16 years, won 200 games, had a really good 117 career ERA+, pitched over 2700 career innings, and had almost 2500 strikeouts. He was the Cy Young runner-up in 2016 (with the Cubs) and had two additional fourth-place finishes when he was with the Red Sox. He’s got a human-interest story, given that he overcame cancer as a young man. And, the big one, he’s a postseason legend: he won World Series twice with Boston and once with the Cubs, and he’s got a career 2.51 ERA in 154 postseason innings (compared to a 3.66 career ERA during the regular season). He was the NLCS MVP during the Cubs’ run in 2016. Hall of Fame chances: I don’t think I’d vote for him, but he’s got a shot long term.
Andrew Miller, Relief Pitcher
Miller, like Davis, dominated the conversation for a bit as a fantastic, Hall-of-Fame level reliever. Like Davis, Miller was a major prospect as a starter (BA had him 10th before the 2007 season), and like Davis, he did not work out as a starter; the first six years of Miller’s career are really rough, in which he had a 5.79 ERA in 359 innings. He first pitched out of the bullpen full time with Boston in 2012 and immediately saw results, and he’s got a six-year run that, like Davis again, is as good as it gets for relievers. From 2012-17, Miller had a 2.01 ERA in 350 appearances, made a couple of All-Star games, and finished in the top 10 in Cy Young voting a couple of times. His biggest moment came in the 2016 postseason with Cleveland, when he started the playoffs with 16 straight scoreless innings—a streak that Aaron Ashby broke this season. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but he was at the level for a few years.
Buster Posey, Catcher
Posey is, in my opinion, the only player with a shot at a first-ballot Hall of Fame induction this season, but it’s far from a given. By rate stats, Posey is clearly one of the best catchers of all time. Among retired catchers who played after 1900, only Hall of Famers Mickey Cochrane and Johnny Bench accrued bWAR at a higher rate; no catcher with significant games played in the history of baseball has a higher fWAR rate than Posey. His 2012 season, in which he won MVP and then helped the Giants win the World Series, is one of the top-five seasons ever by a catcher, in my opinion. Posey also won a Rookie of the Year, made seven All-Star Games, and won two additional World Series.
There might be some hangups over counting stats, though. Posey really only played 11 years (if we leave out the seven games he played in 2009) and had some injury issues at times, so he’s only got 1,371 career games played—that’s fewer than the Hall of Fame candidates who we always think of as too injured to make it, like Nomar Garciaparra, Dustin Pedroia, and David Wright. Posey only had 1,500 career hits (amongst catchers, that’s fewer than Thurman Munson, Javy López, Brad Ausmus, and Brian McCann) and 158 homers (fewer than Terry Steinbach, Charles Johnson, and Cal Raleigh, who is 29 years old). Hall of Fame chances: I think he’s pretty obviously a Hall of Fame catcher, but I don’t really know what his first ballot will look like. Could be anywhere from 40% to 80%.
Pablo Sandoval, Infielder
Posey’s teammate in San Francisco, “Kung Fu Panda” and his, ahem, somewhat round physique delighted fans for 14 years, the best of those coming by the Bay. In his first five seasons, Sandoval had two All-Star appearances and a couple of times showing up on MVP ballots, finishing all the way up at seventh in 2009, and he won three World Series in his first seven years. But conditioning issues hampered his longevity; Sandoval played seven years after 2014 but never again had more than 1.4 WAR. He finished with 1,279 hits, 153 homers, and a 111 OPS+. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Ervin Santana, Starting Pitcher
Santana was just a solid pitcher for a long time in semi-obscurity with the Angels, and he had a bit of a career renaissance in his 30s while pitching with the Twins. Santana appearaed in over 400 games in his career and threw almost 250 innings, and while he was rarely a star, he was just a solid pitcher for a long time. He finished in the top seven in Cy Young voting in 2008 and 2017, which were also his two career All-Star appearances. He finished his career with 151 wins and just shy of 2,000 strikeouts. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Kyle Seager, Third Baseman
Kyle is perhaps most well-known for being Corey’s older brother, but he was a heck of a player in a way that was easy to miss. The elder Seager quietly went about his business in Seattle, and that business was playing good defense and hitting homers. Seager was sort of a 21st century Graig Nettles, in that he never hit for much average (career .251 hitter) but he was a good home-run hitter (242 career homers while playing in the toughest homer park in the league) who walked a decent amount. Seager retired relatively young, at 33, and made just one All-Star Game, but he was a bit of an analytics darling; from 2013-17, he averaged over 5 bWAR per season. Hall of Fame chances: Zero.
Joakim Soria, Relief Pitcher
We’ve made it to one of the two Brewers on the ballot! Soria had most of his career success early: over his first four seasons, he had a 2.01 ERA (218 ERA+) in 255 innings and saved 132 games for the Royals, including two seasons over 40 saves. But after a rough season in 2011, he missed all of 2012 with an injury, and struggled a bit to find it upon returning. He had his moments, but was much more inconsistent than he’d been in his mid-20s. After a good start with the White Sox in 2018, the Brewers acquired the then-34-year-old reliever at the trade deadline; judging by his FIP/ERA split, he had rotten luck as a Brewer, but a 4.09 ERA in 26 appearances isn’t great. He pitched seven times for the Brewers in the postseason but allowed four earned runs in 4 2/3 innings. Soria finished his 14-year career in 2021 with 229 saves and a 137 ERA+. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, but Soria has a case as a top-35-ish reliever of all time.
Ryan Zimmerman, Third Baseman
Zimmerman was, for many years, the face of the fledgling Washington Nationals after they made their move from Montreal. He made his debut in 2005, the Nationals’ first year in Washington, and he spent his whole career there, finishing with 1,846 hits, 284 homers, and 417 doubles in 1,799 games. He got down-ballot MVP votes four times, won the 2019 World Series, won two Silver Sluggers and a Gold Glove, and at his peak (2009-10) was in the discussion as the best third baseman in the league. He’s a bit below Hall of Fame level, but he’s a franchise legend for sure. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, though he could get some votes.
Returning Players
For returning players, I’ll list the player, their position, their vote percentage last season, and their year on the ballot.
Chase Utley, Second Baseman, 59.1%, 4th year
As I’ve written before, Utley is a litmus test for whether you believe in analytics or not. He finished his 16-year career with 1,885 hits, 259 homers, 411 doubles, and 154 stolen bases at an astronomical success rate, with a reputation as a decent defensive second baseman. Those aren’t really Hall-of-Fame numbers on the surface. But if you believe the analytics, Utley was actually one of the best second basemen in the league, a superb all-around player whose peak was as good as any second baseman this side of Joe Morgan. (If you’re a Brewer fan, get on the hype train, because if Brice Turang is ever going to have a Hall-of-Fame argument, it’s likely to look like Utley’s.) Hall of Fame chances: He jumped almost 20 percent last year, and it seems inevitable that he’ll get there. It might be this year, it might not be, but I’m pretty sure it’s coming.
Andy Pettitte, Starting Pitcher, 48.5%, 9th year
Pettitte has a strong-ish case if you just look at the numbers: 256 wins, a 117 career ERA+, five World Series wins, and more wins and innings pitched than any pitcher in baseball history. He’s got nearly 70 fWAR. He would be an easy choice, if not a first-ballot one, in most circumstances. But Pettitte is also an admitted user of HGH, which has kept his vote totals low, even if he’s not nearly as reviled as the Barry Bonds/Roger Clemens/Álex Rodríguez triumvirate. He made a real jump last season—over 20%—but it’s probably too little too late, as he’s got to make up another 27 percent in two years. Hall of Fame chances: Low. No steroid user has broken through; it’d be weird if it was Pettitte.
Félix Hernández, Starting Pitcher, 46.1%, 3rd year
Hernández won a Cy Young in 2010, finished second twice, and finished fourth another time. From roughly 2009-2014 he was, anecdotally, one of the best pitchers in the league, and his Cy Young win—in a season in which he went just 13-12—is viewed as a watershed moment for the analytics movement. Hernández also made a massive jump in vote percentage last year, about 26%, and given that he’s a fan favorite who does not have the steroid questions that Pettitte does, and that the way we evaluate starting pitchers’ careers is changing, it seems likely that Hernández is going to make it eventually, despite just 169 career wins.
Álex Rodríguez, Infielder, 40.0%, 6th year
There’s obviously no question about Rodríguez’s ability—he’s probably one of the 30 or so greatest baseball players in history. But he’s a weirdo who everyone dislikes who definitely did lots of steroids, so his 3,115 hits, 696 homers, 2,086 RBI, three MVPs, and two Gold Gloves will just be memories, as far as the Hall of Fame goes. Hall of Fame chances: I think it’s safe to say zero, unless something crazy happens in the next five years.
Bobby Abreu, Outfielder, 30.8%, 8th year
Abreu is one of these guys who people just can’t really believe: in a seven-year stretch from 1998-2004, Abreu averaged—averaged—5.9 WAR, 23 homers, 94 RBI, 29 stolen bases, 41 doubles, and six triples per season while hitting .308/.416/.525. No one noticed, because he was playing the corner outfield for a bad team in Philadelphia. By the time he was under much brighter lights in New York and Los Angeles, he was on the wrong side of 30, and while still a solid player, was no longer a star. Still: 60.2 bWAR, 2,470 hits, 288 homers, 400 stolen bases and a 128 career OPS+. Abreu suffers from this idea that he was “not a big enough star,” and okay, whatever. Hall of Fame chances: Pretty low. Three years left and a lot of ground to make up. I think he deserves it, though.
Jimmy Rollins, Shortstop, 25.4%, 6th year
The third of four prominent Philadelphia Phillies in this group, Rollins played 17 years, accrued 2,455 hits, had over 500 doubles and 115 triples (a huge number for a modern player), hit with pop (231 homers), stole bases (470 steals), played good enough defense to win four Gold Gloves, and won an MVP in 2007 when he led the league in runs scored and triples, hit 30 homers and 38 doubles, stole 41 bases in 47 tries, and won a Gold Glove. Analytics are not especially kind to Rollins; he had just a .324 career OBP and 95 career OPS+, and while his counting stats look pretty solid, he spent much of his career in one of the biggest offensive eras in league history and thus doesn’t look as good when comparing to his peers. Hall of Fame chances: Not zero, but not very good.
Cole Hamels, Starting Pitcher, 23.8%, 2nd year
The last of the Phillies here, Hamels has a surprising amount of bWAR (59, which is 19 more than Lester, for example). It’s interesting to compare him to Hernández; King Félix is pretty universally considered a better pitcher, but Hamels had basically the same number of wins (163) and had a 123 career ERA+ compared to Hernández’s 117. Hamels was basically just never bad, and though he never rose to Cy Young levels (he never finished higher than fifth), he just had a long, productive career. He also had a legendary postseason run in 2008, when he was the MVP of the NLCS and the World Series; in three starts in those two series, he went 3-0 and allowed just three runs in 22 innings. Hall of Fame chances: It depends a lot on this year, I think—he needs to make a big jump, but 23.8% is a really good showing in his first season.
Dustin Pedroia, Second Baseman, 20.7%, 3rd year
Pedroia’s career is viewed by many to be too short to be a Hall of Famer, but as mentioned, he played over 100 more games than Posey did. Pedroia has over 50 career WAR, he won an MVP and a Rookie of the Year, and won three Gold Gloves and a Silver Slugger. It was basically over at age 33, but prior to the injuries that plagued him after his 30th birthday, Pedroia was cruising toward 3,000 hits, 600 doubles, and a first-ballot situation. I’d make a strong argument for him, which I might do next week. Hall of Fame chances: Low, but not entirely nonexistent.
Mark Buehrle, Starting Pitcher, 20.0%, 7th year
Buehrle is kind of a favorite amongst the people who cheer for him. He, like Hamels, had 59 career WAR; he won over 200 games, was the best pitcher on a team that cruised to a World Series, he threw a perfect game, and he made five All-Star teams and won four Gold Gloves. But his number one trait is his consistency: no pitcher in modern baseball history can boast the consistency with which Buehrle did his job. From his first full season in 2001 until his last year in 2015, Buehrle never made fewer than 30 starts, and the only time he missed 200 innings pitched was in his last season… when he had 198 2/3. Hall of Fame chances: Almost zero, but he rules, and I think you can make a case.
Omar Vizquel, Shortstop, 18.4%, 10th year
Vizquel looked to be on his way to the Hall, and then there were gross allegations and his support tanked. I’m good with that for reasons both personal and baseball: as a baseball player, he did get up to 2,877 hits and he was one of the great defensive shortstops, but he was a bad hitter (career 82 OPS+) who got to the numbers he did simply by playing for an immense amount of time (24 seasons). Vizquel only topped four WAR once in his career, and that’s just not a Hall of Famer for me. Hall of Fame chances: Zero, at least via the BBWAA. Could see a committee put him in some day.
David Wright, Third Baseman, 14.8%, 4th year
Wright, like Pedroia, has what I consider a real case despite the general feeling that his career was too short because of injuries. From 2005-2013 he was one of the best players in the league, and had three seasons of at least 6.9 WAR, topping out at 8.3 in 2007. He won two Gold Gloves and two Silver Sluggers, and I think in retrospect that he deserved the 2007 MVP (he finished fourth). He finished with 1,777 hits, 390 doubles, 242 homers, 196 stolen bases, and a 133 OPS+, but that’s too little for most voters. Hall of Fame chances: Basically zero, but I kind of disagree.
Francisco Rodríguez, Relief Pitcher, 11.8%, 5th year
Here is the second former Brewer on the list! K-Rod has his own off-the-field issues, but he’s sixth all time with 437 saves, and the 62 saves he had in 2008 are five more than anyone else has ever had in a season. I’d put Rodríguez in the top 12-or-so relievers of all time, but… how many relievers should really be in the Hall of Fame? It’s a tough question. Hall of Fame chances: He’s not going to make it, but it makes sense that he’s sticking around the ballot.
Torii Hunter, Outfielder, 8.7%, 7th year
Hunter has a great qualitative case. He hit 353 homers, had almost 2,500 hits, and was known in his time as one of the best, if not the best, defensive center fielders in the game. But analytics haven’t been so kind to Hunter: he’s got only 50.6 career bWAR, mostly because 1) he didn’t walk much and 2) his defense was probably not quite as good as we all thought it was. Mileage varies on those conclusions, though, so he’s stuck around for seven years, though this could be the year he falls under 5%. Hall of Fame chances: another one that a committee could do something surprising with one day. Heck, he’d be a better inductee than Harold Baines.

















